Why Your Health Goals Don't Need More Willpower

For decades, we've been sold a compelling story about health behavior change: if you want to eat better, exercise more, or build healthier habits, you just need more willpower. Power through the discomfort. Push harder. Stay strong. These statements ooze modern stoicism, alpha-human dogma, dare I say finance bro or tech-bro “ism”. Don’t get me wrong, I am all about achieving extraordinary goals and putting in the work. 

But what if the push harder, push through narrative isn't just unhelpful – what if it's fundamentally wrong?

As a naturopathic doctor and physician health coach the “W” word comes up entirely too often, but when working with patients I don’t discredit the concept outright. Instead, I prefer to focus on alternative attributes like attention, values, confidence, and acceptance. 

Recent research and my personal insight from thousands of health behavior change consultations, suggests that successful health behavior change has far less to do with white-knuckling your way through temptation and much more to do with four key factors: your core values, your confidence in your ability to change, your ability to maintain attention on process, and your willingness to accept discomfort as part of the journey

The Myth of the Willpower Muscle

The idea that willpower is like a muscle that can be depleted – known as the "ego depletion" theory – gained massive popularity following influential research in the late 1990s. The famous "cookie study" by Baumeister showed that people who resisted eating cookies performed worse on subsequent tasks requiring self-control, suggesting their willpower had been "used up."

However, evidence evolves. A landmark 2016 study involving 23 laboratories and over 2,000 participants failed to replicate these findings. Additional meta-analyses have suggested that if willpower depletion exists at all, its effects are far smaller than originally believed.

Even more telling, research by Job and colleagues found that people's beliefs about willpower itself influenced their behavior more than any actual depletion. Those who believed willpower was unlimited showed no signs of depletion at all.

What Really Drives Lasting Change?

If willpower isn't the answer, what is? Modern research points to four key factors:

1. Values Alignment

When health goals connect deeply with our core values – what truly matters to us – change becomes more sustainable. Instead of asking "Do I have enough willpower to exercise today?" try asking "How does moving my body align with my values of being an energetic parent or living life fully?"

2. Attention

Attention or prosoché (pro-so-kay)in ancient Greek is fundamentally attached to the Stoic philosophy and the aim to live virtuously. Ultimately, maintaining attention and presence and being PRESENT with that PLAN on a consistent, sustainable basis, can be the difference maker. 

3. Self-Efficacy (Confidence)

Our belief in our ability to change matters enormously. This isn't about positive thinking – it's about building genuine confidence through small wins and gradual progress. Start with changes so small they seem almost trivial, and build from there.

4. Psychological Flexibility (Acceptance)

Rather than trying to eliminate discomfort or cravings through sheer force of will, successful change often involves accepting these experiences while still moving toward our goals. This might mean acknowledging the desire for processed foods while still choosing nourishing alternatives, or feeling the resistance to exercise while putting on your running shoes anyway.

***A quick sidebar here: When someone comes to a doctor, they may not be ready for a “deep work” strategy. As a result I have lost innumerable patients and clients due to the fact that they were not ready to engage with this paradigm. For some, believing that 

Building a Better Approach to Change

Instead of focusing on strengthening willpower, try these evidence-based strategies:

1. Create supportive environments: Rather than relying on moment-to-moment willpower, design your environment to make healthy choices easier. You may have to architect your life with people, places, and activities in some less-than-comfortable changes at first. 

2. Develop specific plans: Use "if-then" implementation intentions to handle challenging situations before they arise.

3. Connect with your values: Regularly reflect on how your health goals connect with what matters most to you. What is the real value vs. the expected value of behavior “X” and does it align with a more authentic version of how you want to be related to your health?

4. Build competence and confidence gradually: Start with changes that feel achievable, and slowly expand your comfort zone.

5. Practice acceptance: Replace self-criticism over "lack of willpower" with understanding and encouragement.

The Path Forward

The shift away from willpower-based models of change isn't just theoretical – it's liberating. It means we can stop blaming ourselves for lacking something that might not even exist in the way we thought it did.

Instead, we can focus on building sustainable systems, connecting with our values, and developing the confidence and flexibility needed for lasting change. This approach isn't always easier than trying to force change through willpower alone, but it's ultimately more effective and sustainable.

The next time you feel yourself falling short of a health goal, instead of berating yourself for lacking willpower, try asking:

- How does this goal connect with what truly matters to me?

- What small steps could help me build confidence in this area?

- Can I accept the discomfort that comes with change while still moving forward?

The answers to these questions – not the strength of your willpower – will likely determine your success.

---

*This article synthesizes research from multiple sources in behavioral science and psychology. While the willpower-as-resource model was popularized by early studies (Baumeister, 1998; Gailliot, 2007), more recent research has challenged this view, suggesting a more nuanced understanding of behavior change (Hagger et al., 2016; Job et al., 2010; Inzlicht & Friese, 2019).*